logo image

ATD Blog

New Rules in Leadership: Overcoming Toxic Command and Control

By

Thu Oct 17 2024

Adobe Stock 253252230.jpg
Loading...

Brought to you by

In today’s world, leadership ideas are shifting, challenging long-standing practices. The traditional “command and control” style, where leaders make all the decisions, is being replaced by trust and collaboration. Leaders are now moving away from micromanagement and embracing team autonomy. If you’re responsible for leadership training, it’s important to understand how adopting these new approaches early can have a big impact.

Let’s break it down.

Advertisement

A Lesson From Science: Big Ideas That Change Everything

To understand the impact of big ideas in leadership, consider how major scientific breakthroughs transformed the world. For example:

  • Galileo and Newton described how objects move through space and time.

  • Maxwell and Lorentz built on their work, showing that the speed of light is constant regardless of how an observer moves.

  • Einstein then developed his famous theory of relativity, leading to the discovery that a small amount of mass could be turned into enormous energy—this led to nuclear energy.

These ideas didn’t come overnight, but their impact has been profound. Nuclear energy, for example, reshaped international politics and power dynamics, with countries that control nuclear energy gaining major advantages.

How This Applies to Leadership

Just like those big scientific ideas, leadership is undergoing a transformation. For years, leaders have managed teams through strict top-down control. Leaders gave orders, and teams followed them. But this old way of leading is giving way to something new.

The emerging leadership model is based on:

  • Trust and Interdependence: Instead of controlling everything, leaders are learning to trust their teams to make decisions at the right levels.

  • Clear Goals: Teams and leaders agree on measurable goals, and everyone is accountable for achieving them.

  • Collaboration: Leaders work with their teams to make decisions, rather than just giving orders.

  • A “Speak-Up” Culture: Leaders encourage open communication, knowing the best ideas can come from anywhere.

  • Belonging Over Conformity: Leaders focus on building a sense of belonging within the team, instead of forcing everyone to fit a mold.

This shift allows teams to make decisions faster, avoid micromanagement, and reduce internal politics. As a result, teams led by transformational leaders are far more productive.

Advertisement

Why Leaders Should Adopt These New Ideas

Jim Collins, in his book Good to Great, describes transformational leaders as “Level 5” leaders. These leaders drive extraordinary results by empowering their teams through trust and accountability. The benefits of adopting these new leadership approaches are clear:

  • Faster Decision Making: Routine decisions happen quickly because they’re made by the people closest to the situation.

  • Less Bureaucracy: Reducing administrative overhead means less time wasted on politics or approval processes.

  • Increased Productivity: Teams thrive when they have autonomy and a clear vision to guide them.

Creating a Transformational Leadership Training Program

Transformational leadership training involves more than just teaching concepts. It requires a strategic approach that encourages new behaviors and practices. There are four pillars to an effective training program:

Set Goals
Teach leaders to understand the big-picture qualitative outcomes they’re after—and the metrics they will use to define progress transparently. Leaders must learn how to set team goals collaboratively and ensure individual goals are deeply aligned.

Identify Barriers
Barriers can be external factors like market trends and technological disruption—or internal factors like team dynamics and individual habits. Leaders must learn how to create an environment for honest, sometimes difficult, conversations.

Change Behavior
Teach leaders to treat every change as an experiment and encourage teams to change together—creating an environment that nurtures progress patterns. Lasting team momentum requires individual understanding and consent. It can be inspired, but not coerced.

Advertisement

Evaluate Results
Show leaders how to guide their teams in continually comparing performance against metrics, updating goals and experiments based on clear evidence.

By implementing these pillars, you can help your leaders transition from traditional command-and-control styles to transformational leadership, significantly enhancing your organization’s productivity.

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In


Copyright © 2024 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy