logo image

ATD Blog

When the Competency Model Breaks Down: How to Map Skills to Roles

By

Wed Jan 15 2020

When the Competency Model Breaks Down: How to Map Skills to Roles
Loading...

By now, most of us have caught on to the idea that talking about skills is cool, and many companies are simply replacing the word learning with skills. While this idea is taking over the L&D world, many professionals are facing challenges in reconciling this idea with their companies’ pre-existing competency models.

The problem with competency maps is they evolve so quickly and they’re often outdated before being approved and published. And who really knows how to measure the broad statements they often contain, such as, “ . . . Treats customers with empathy and kindness while expediently resolving their issues?” Maybe that’s why organizations also have committees to calibrate the resulting competency measurement processes.

Advertisement

So we understand the complexity around competency models, but what’s the alternative? Our solution: mapping skills to roles to quantify ability and create visibility. Once you’ve mapped, you measure, modify, and share what you’re learning with the data. We can help with these five steps.

1. Start With Why

This is the fundamental business reason why you’re measuring skills. For most organizations, the main driver is growth, whether that is in size, in new markets, or in new products and services to future-proof your organization.

Don’t stop there, though. Remember that you must get this data from people. And to get the most accurate data, it’s best to avoid highly pressurized moments, like promotions or raises. Another best practice is to identify a “why” for each individual, which is often a version of career progression, especially if it occurs within the organization (think internal mobility).

2. Focus on a Few Roles to Start

Remember that one of the reasons competency models don’t work is their complexity. They’re layered and wordy, so let’s not repeat that mistake. When crafting your solution, focus on a few critical roles to start. Maybe you start with growth roles or high-performing departments—even a horizontal role, like a manager or business analyst. Or perhaps you focus on important skills for new hires, like going back to the basics.

3. Map Skills to Roles

After selecting a handful of crucial roles, it’s time to map skills to them. Sounds easy, right? It can be but there are a few common challenges:

Advertisement
  • Too Many: Recall where we went off the road with competencies and avoid doing too much. This makes it challenging to hit the goal identified in step one. In other words, it will make it difficult to glean immediate insights.

  • Non-Critical: The reality is that every one of us is a complex system of skills. Some of these skills help us to be successful in our current role while others may be completely unrelated to the current role. And some are supporting but maybe not critical. It’s the last group that organizations might include when they really aren’t necessary.

  • Top-Down: Our recent report with Harvard Business Publishing Corporate Learning in How the Workforce Learns shows that our employees know their skills and skills gaps. So why aren’t we asking them? You’ll get better input along with better output to meet your goal.

4. Measure, Monitor, Modify

You need to measure but also monitor often and modify based on what you’re seeing. Say you’re looking at project management and noticing that everyone’s level is the same. To get insight, you need to modify what you’re seeing. Perhaps project management isn’t the skill that distinguishes great performance (and great performance is what you need to meet your goal). So, remove it and find the skills that are driving your business forward.

5. Share Your Insights

This one may seem obvious but too often we stop at the measuring stage, so we don’t fully realize the impact of our insights. These insights can lead to changes in job requirements and the opening of talent pools. That can lead to more growth. Find those connections in your data and share them, far and wide.

You've Reached ATD Member-only Content

Become an ATD member to continue

Already a member?Sign In

Advertisement

Copyright © 2024 ATD

ASTD changed its name to ATD to meet the growing needs of a dynamic, global profession.

Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCookie Policy